Back to Search Results
$737,500sold price Closed

437 Selma Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119

5 bd | 2 ba | 2,928 sq ft | Historic,Traditional
Subdivision: Chestnuts At Selma
A rare opportunity to be the next caretakers of a very special century home embodying the majestic history of Webster Groves. This is the quintessential Webster home you've been holding out for! This home is featured on the 32nd Annual Webster Groves Holiday House Tour. Located a block away from beautiful Blackburn Park, The Matthew T. Chestnut home is the original farmhouse that sat on 80 plus original acres in Webster Groves. The Chestnut family holds the namesake for many of the surrounding Street names in the neighborhood, and the home boasts it's very own feature in Marilynne Bradley's book, A City of Century Homes: A Centennial History of Webster Groves Missouri. The current owners have extensive historical information and photos of the original family history they'd love to share. This 5 bedroom 2 bath home is a stunner with original period millwork - much of it untouched - 4 pairs of 8 ft walnut pocket doors, 4 of the 5 original fireplaces, restored original hardwood floors and almost .75 acre of park-like grounds with unlimited possibilities for beautiful gardens. The huge driveway will come in handy for your large gatherings. The dramatic deep front yard with mature trees leads to a large and welcoming covered porch. Step through the original double doors into the a grand foyer and admire the gorgeous original front staircase, original stained glass and one of 4 original fireplaces, each an ode to specific tree varieties once on the property. To the left is the quintessential library, so warm and inviting, that beckons curling up with your favorite drink and a good book. The 2nd original fireplace with hand carved mantle is a beautiful focal point, along with the Restoration Hardware lighting. Through the library to the living room you will find more beautiful original woodwork, remarkable carved oak mantel and gas insert for cozy fire nights. Look up to find a stunning carved ceiling medallion and designer lighting, elegant curved walls, black Jeld-Wen windows and display nook. The large dining room will hold a table for 12+, contains a roomy coat closet and is anchored by a stunning Ralph Lauren 9-Light chandelier. The main level has great flow for entertaining! The darling cottagecore kitchen with designer appliances, quartz sink and an abundance of natural light is sure to delight any home chef. An updated full bath and bonus main floor laundry room rounds out the main floor. A second staircase takes you upstairs past more original stained glass to the 2nd floor where you'll find another full bathroom clad with marble tile and designer details, plenty of bedrooms for a growing family, and elegant owners suite with the 4th decorative fireplace in rich wood and an attached 5th bedroom that leads to a huge enclosed sunporch. The cutest staircase leads you up to a breathtaking 3rd floor bathed in light. The options upstairs are endless - family room, playroom, office, or an another bedroom, the flexibility of this 3rd floor space is just icing on the cake after touring this home. The current owners worked with well-known award winning architects to produce 2 sets of Webster approved plans, one for a luxurious kitchen and mudroom addition and the other for a custom primary bathroom and luxury closet room in place of the 5th bedroom. Plans are already approved and will be available for viewing. Webster has also approved a pool on the property and the contract may be negotiated, though there is no pool installed yet. Important brand new updates include new Owens Corning architectural 30 yr roof, all new high efficiency HVAC, refinished hardwoods, new premium carpet in upstairs hallway, new 50g water heater, new copper water line from street service. Walk to gorgeous parks, award winning schools and restaurants, the Webster Rec center and the booming Old Orchard district from this amazing location. This is the perfect Webster Groves life!

Status: Closed · MLS# 25080077 · Listing Courtesy of Compass Realty Group, [email protected]
Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.

Approximate location. Get directions

See this home with a live agent, right now

Talk to a MORE, REALTORS® agent, not a referral call center. Why that matters to what you pay

Call now
Calls may be recorded.*
How live works
Your MORE, REALTORS® agent
Trusted local partners

Facts and features

Sold Price

$ 737,500

List Price

$ 750,000

Status

Closed

Days on market

40

MLS#

25080077

Bedrooms

5

Full baths

2

Sq. Ft. Above

2,928

Subdivision

Chestnuts At Selma

Municipality

Webster Groves

School District

Webster Groves

County

St Louis

Property Type

Residential

Style

Historic,Traditional

Type

Residential

Additional Information

Property Tax (2024)

$7,109

Room Dimensions

Main level
Living Room
15 × 15 ft · 225 sq ft
Dining Room
15 × 14 ft · 210 sq ft
Kitchen
15 × 12 ft · 180 sq ft
Family Room
15 × 15 ft · 225 sq ft
Laundry
14 × 9 ft · 126 sq ft
Upper level
Sitting Room
26 × 9 ft · 234 sq ft
Game Room
47 × 15 ft · 705 sq ft
Second
Primary Bedroom
15 × 15 ft · 225 sq ft
Bedroom 2
14 × 11 ft · 154 sq ft
Bedroom 3
14 × 10 ft · 140 sq ft
Bedroom 4
11 × 11 ft · 121 sq ft
Bedroom 5
11 × 11 ft · 121 sq ft

Recent Nearby Sales in 63119

Last 6 closed homes in this zip.

Address Bd/Ba SqFt List Sold Closed
1472 Grant Road, Webster Groves, MO 63119 3/2 1,178 $279,900 $260,000
92.9% of ask
Nov 19, 2026
7334 Devonshire Avenue, Shrewsbury, MO 63119 3/2 1,644 $449,900 $435,000
96.7% of ask
Nov 18, 2026
545 Marshall Avenue, Webster Groves, MO 63119 4/1 1,928 $419,900 $425,000
101.2% of ask
Nov 16, 2026
147 Kenilworth Avenue, Webster Groves, MO 63119 3/2 1,818 $575,000 $575,000
100% of ask
Nov 13, 2026
5420 Kenrick Parke Drive, Shrewsbury, MO 63119 3/3 2,023 $268,450 $255,000
95% of ask
Nov 13, 2026
521 Barcia Dr, Rock Hill, MO 63119 3/2 1,319 $219,900 $205,000
93.2% of ask
Nov 13, 2026

Price & Listing History

Listed for sale at $750,000
Dec 18, 2025
Sold for $737,500
Jan 27, 2026 · 98.3% of original list price · 40 days from listing to closing

Every time this home was on the market

Prior listings, expired and canceled listings, days on market, price changes and sold prices from MARIS MLS records.

Loading…

Most MLS-recorded sales near this home

Most closed sales in the last 12 months around this address, listing side and buyer side, plus this listing agent's record.

Loading…

Mortgage Estimator

Estimate your monthly payment. Adjust the sliders below.

Estimated Monthly Payment
$0
Principal & Interest: $0 · Tax: $0 · Ins: $0
Loan Amount: $0
Total Interest: $0
Total of Payments: $0
A MORE, REALTORS® agent will connect you with a trusted local lender.

Prefilled with the national 30 year fixed average, 7.28% as of Nov 19, 2026 (Freddie Mac). Your rate will differ. Estimate only. Not a loan offer. Consult a lender for an accurate quote, including HOA fees, PMI, and current rates.

Video or audio, usually in about 2 minutes. How it works

Other homes for sale nearby

In Webster Groves, 63119, closest in price to this one. See all in 63119 →
5029 Glennon Drive, Shrewsbury, MO, 63119 - 5 bed, 6 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$747,000

Price drop $22,000 was $769,000
814 Clark Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119 - 3 bed, 4 bath home for sale in Webster Groves, MO

$715,000

7 days on STLMLS
814 Clark Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119
3bd|4ba|2,275sqft|$314/sqft|7 DOM|2 Story MLS#26070400
669 Marshall Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119 - 5 bed, 3 bath home for sale in Webster Groves, MO

$709,900

Price drop $40,100 was $750,000
669 Marshall Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119
5bd|3ba|3,029sqft|$234/sqft|42 DOM|2 Story MLS#26063009
330 S Forest Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119 - 4 bed, 4 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$799,000

23 days on STLMLS
330 S Forest Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119
4bd|4ba|2,612sqft|$306/sqft|23 DOM|2 Story MLS#26068974
140 S Old Orchard Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119 - 5 bed, 5 bath home for sale in Webster Groves, MO

$799,900

Price drop $95,100 was $895,000
429 S Rock Hill Road, Webster Groves, MO, 63119 - 3 bed, 4 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO
Pending

$799,900

2 days on STLMLS
520 Sherwood Drive, Webster Groves, MO, 63119 - 3 bed, 3 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO
Pending

$700,000

New listing
28 S Maple Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119 - 4 bed, 2 bath home for sale in Webster Groves, MO
Pending

$840,000

10 days on STLMLS
28 S Maple Avenue, Webster Groves, MO, 63119
4bd|2ba|2,644sqft|$318/sqft|10 DOM|2.5 Story MLS#26067393