Back to Search Results
$231,600 Pending

111 E McKinley Street, Hayti, MO, 63851

4 bd | 3 ba | 4,088 sq ft | Ranch
Subdivision: Morgans
If you’re drawn to homes with character and ready to write the next chapter, this early-1900s gem is waiting for you! Full of early 1900s charm, this two story home offers historic character, solid bones, and generous space for someone ready to bring it back to life. With its American Four Square architecture, tall ceilings, and original details, the property reflects the craftsmanship of its era and provides a wonderful canvas for restoration. Inside, the traditional layout features spacious rooms, large windows, original woodwork, wood floors and the warm, timeless appeal of early century design. In addition to two full stories of living space, the home includes a full basement—ideal for storage, workshop space, or future finishing—and a large attic that adds even more potential for expansion or creative use. Situated on 117,612 sq ft (approx. 2.70 acres), the property offers a remarkably spacious yard with room for outdoor living, gardening, or future improvements. While the home does need some TLC, the possibilities are wide open. Whether you’re an investor, a renovator, or someone who loves the charm of older homes, this property offers the chance to restore a piece of Hayti’s history and make it truly shine.

Status: Pending · MLS# 26056992 · Listing Courtesy of American Elite Realty

Approximate location. Get directions

See this home with a live agent, right now

Talk to a MORE, REALTORS® agent, not a referral call center. Why that matters to what you pay

Call now
Calls may be recorded.*
How live works
Your MORE, REALTORS® agent
Trusted local partners

Facts and features

List Price

$ 231,600

Status

Pending

Days on market

0

MLS#

26056992

Bedrooms

4

Full baths

3

Sq. Ft. Above

4,088

Sq. Ft. Below

1,000

Subdivision

Morgans

School District

Hayti R-II

County

Pemiscot

Property Type

Residential

Style

Ranch

Type

Residential

Additional Information

Property Tax (2025)

$837

Recent Nearby Sales in 63851

Last 6 closed homes in this zip.

Address Bd/Ba SqFt List Sold Closed
603 Kristina Reed Street, Hayti, MO 63851 4/3 3,663 $225,000 $220,000
97.8% of ask
Oct 29, 2026
301 E Jackson, Hayti, MO 63851 4/2 1,674 $100,000 $93,000
93% of ask
Oct 1, 2026
605 W Main Street, Hayti, MO 63851 3/2 1,624 $39,900 $30,000
75.2% of ask
Aug 7, 2026
204 S Moore Street, Hayti, MO 63851 3/2 2,880 $149,000 $130,000
87.2% of ask
Jun 30, 2026
0 County Road 258, Hayti, MO 63851 0/0 -- $600,000 $583,800
97.3% of ask
May 19, 2026
706 Carleton Avenue, Caruthersville, MO 63851 5/2 3,120 $290,000 $295,000
101.7% of ask
Feb 12, 2026

Price & Listing History

Listed for sale at $231,600
Sep 4, 2026
Current status: Pending
As of Sep 16, 2026 · $231,600

Every time this home was on the market

Prior listings, expired and canceled listings, days on market, price changes and sold prices from MARIS MLS records.

Loading…

Most MLS-recorded sales near this home

Most closed sales in the last 12 months around this address, listing side and buyer side, plus this listing agent's record.

Loading…

Mortgage Estimator

Estimate your monthly payment. Adjust the sliders below.

Estimated Monthly Payment
$0
Principal & Interest: $0 · Tax: $0 · Ins: $0
Loan Amount: $0
Total Interest: $0
Total of Payments: $0
A MORE, REALTORS® agent will connect you with a trusted local lender.

Prefilled with the national 30 year fixed average, 7.28% as of Nov 19, 2026 (Freddie Mac). Your rate will differ. Estimate only. Not a loan offer. Consult a lender for an accurate quote, including HOA fees, PMI, and current rates.

Video or audio, usually in about 2 minutes. How it works

Other homes for sale nearby

In Hayti, 63851, closest in price to this one. See all in 63851 →
500 Kristina Reed Street, Hayti, MO, 63851 - 4 bed, 3 bath home for sale in Hayti, MO

$275,000

29 days on STLMLS
500 Kristina Reed Street, Hayti, MO, 63851
4bd|3ba|2,102sqft|$131/sqft|29 DOM|1.5 Story MLS#26067983
260 County Highway 250, Hayti, MO, 63851 - 3 bed, 1 bath home for sale in Hayti, MO

$49,500

35 days on STLMLS
260 County Highway 250, Hayti, MO, 63851
3bd|1ba|1,354sqft|$37/sqft|35 DOM|1 Story MLS#26066634
551 Vista Drive, Hayti, MO, 63851 - 1 bed, 1 bath home for sale in Hayti, MO

$19,900

Price drop $5,100 was $25,000
551 Vista Drive, Hayti, MO, 63851
1bd|1ba|1,000sqft|$20/sqft|94 DOM|1 Story MLS#26052810